In a 2006 study, “Behaving Badly,” researcher James Montier found that 74% of the 300 professional fund managers surveyed believed that they had delivered above-average job performance. Of the remaining 26% surveyed, the majority viewed themselves as average. Incredibly, almost 100% of the survey group believed that their job performance was average or better. Clearly, only 50% of the sample can be above average, suggesting the irrationally high level of overconfidence these fund managers exhibited.

Confidence implies realistically trusting in one’s abilities, while overconfidence usually implies an overly optimistic assessment of one’s knowledge or control over a situation.

As you can imagine, overconfidence (i.e., overestimating or exaggerating one’s ability to successfully perform a particular task) is not a trait that applies only to fund managers. Consider the number of times that you’ve participated in a competition or contest with the attitude that you have what it takes to win—regardless of the number of competitors or the fact that there can only be one winner.

Keep in mind that there’s a fine line between confidence and overconfidence.


Overconfident Investing

In terms of investing, overconfidence can be detrimental to your stock-picking ability in the long run. In a 1998 study, “Volume, Volatility, Price, and Profit When All Traders Are Above Average,” researcher Terrance Odean found that overconfident investors generally conduct more trades than their less-confident counterparts.

Odean found that overconfident investors/traders tend to believe they are better than others at choosing the best stocks and best times to enter/exit a position. However, these traders who conducted the most trades tended, on average, to receive significantly lower yields than the market.


Avoiding Overconfidence

Keep in mind that professional fund managers, who have access to the best investment/industry reports and computational models in the business, can still struggle at achieving market-beating returns. The best fund managers know that each investment day presents a new set of challenges and that investment techniques constantly need refining. Just about every overconfident investor is only a trade away from a very humbling wake-up call.

Investing involves risk, including possible loss of principal.

AMG Distributors, Inc., is a member of FINRA/SIPC.

2 Min Read

More Like This

Overreaction and the Availability Bias

Overreaction occurs when one reacts to a piece of news in a way that is greater than the actual impact of the news.

Read More

Prospect Theory

Prospect theory refers to an idea created by Drs. Kahneman and Tversky, which essentially determined that people do not associate equal levels of joy and pain with the same effect. The average individuals tend to be more loss sensitive (in the sense that they will feel more pain experiencing a loss compared to the amount of joy felt from receiving an equal amount of gain).

Read More

The Pitfalls of Emotional Investing, and How to Avoid Them

The market goes up. The market goes down. Volatility, sometimes extreme, is a fact of life. Successful investors understand this and know how to prepare and act accordingly.

Read More